Enviro(ish)
  • Blog
  • Meet Megan
  • Legal(ish)

Everyday Eco: In the wake of soundbites

10/6/2015

12 Comments

 
So often what I face in my day-to-day eco-worklife is the same issue that we all face in our day-to-day lives.  Soundbites.  People who have already heard all they want to hear [insert person covering their ears and saying 'la la la laaaa'].  There are real hazards of people not being able to listen with empathy and understand another perspective.  We all have an inherent fear and ego of allowing ourselves to be challenged (let alone be proven wrong).  But it’s an absolute must, not just on the society but on the personal level.

I have so many posts I’ve wanted to write these last months as I transitioned jobs and made big life changes to a shiny new city.  This is the thing I wanted to say that tipped the scales (never fear though, Pope-est with the Mostest and Laudato Si will be coming in hot. Soon.)  And it’s all thanks to a communications lead at Monsanto.
​
Last year I came to SXSW Eco and sat in the panel session when Monsanto underwent what I can only describe as a live feeding frenzy of pent-up anti-GMO fervor.   A courageous woman from Monsanto did one of the bravest things I’ve ever seen from a sustainability professional: she invited more conversation in the heat of the moment.  Which is exactly what these most thorny issues desperately need the most.  Real dialogue.  But how do we get there?  How do we increase everyone’s personal responsibility to listen better?
Picture
Photo courtesy of: https://canadiansituations.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/monsanto-protest_7946.jpg
On the issue itself, ever since reading a compelling article about GMOs helping reduce pesticides for oranges I’ve landed on the place that what people rail against in anti-GMO is really against a subset of GMOs and the entire science has gotten runover in the frenzy.  I can't say I'm excited at the idea of plants making their own pesticides (freaked out too!), but I'm open to learning what science has to say about it.   To understand the technology used in GMOs is to understand better how science has and will continue to work. (Thank you Microbiology class as part of my failed attempt to be pre-med in college…at least that C+ counts for something on this basic know how!)  The CTO of Monsanto just spoke here at the conference and connected this conversation with the larger anti-science themes that crop up (pun intended) in climate change and vaccines.  Dude has a point.  Seriously. 

But this post is not about the issue.  It’s about listening.  And why we don’t do more of it.  Ultimately that all comes down to the harsh truth that has led us all to soundbites.  All of us.  Every person likes to think that they deep dive into issues and are above the fray of soundbites…and yet none of us have enough time *to* dive into issues to the extent we should.  Case in point, who reads every label of the products they buy? I’m *in* sustainability and I don’t (I do buy from brands I trust to be more eco, but then like a normal consumer, call it a day).

In the wake of the overwhelming amount of issues and the intensity in which people often scream about them, we all do one thing consistently.  Listen to people we trust.  This is the reason why Facebook is so powerful on the whole and why marketers always strive for that precious word of mouth.  Except it has one big gaping risk: the echochamber.  People who agree with each other often segregate themselves into a subcommunity that agrees with itself, ad infinitum.

So it’s important to listen to the other perspective and to find ways and hacks so that you become truly open to new information.  Mine?  I thank my lucky enviroish stars that the first weekend in college I met the woman who would become one of my best friends.  She is a conservative from a sheep and cattle ranch in the northwest of Colorado and one of the most intelligent people I know.  The issues that crop up in her life of agricultural law challenge me to think about my progressive environmental stances.  In the last week, her family’s ranch was a story on NPR Marketplace regarding pay and I know that because I know her, I listened more deeply on this issue. I cherish our relationship all the more because we don't always agree and can be respectful about it.

I’m here at SXSW Eco again, and yet again it’s my favorite sustainability/environmental conference.  Kind of this small-d democratic counteroffering to the traditional big sustainability conferences.  Example.  Yesterday in a panel about how tech is helping on palm oil, the panel is Rainforest Action Network (activist NGO), WRI (solutions/big NGO), a major chocolate company, and a palm oil plantation company.  Points were debated and refined in real time among these various stakeholders and it was amazeballs.  Challenge. Your. Thinking.  Then rinse, repeat.

Last year at this conference, I sat in the audience at a panel on GMOs that put Monsanto in the crosshairs.  And how did they respond?  They brought their CTO this year and committed to engaging with consumers in conversation on these issues.  Acknowledging that they are scientists that talked to farmers but not the public at large and need to do better at communications.  The correlation to climate scientists is obvious and real.  And I admire the backbone of their company culture to stay engaged in the conversation.  The power of Legal inside corporate America is a very real factor that can impede open dialogue, and so I take a huge hats off to Monsanto for deepening their engagement in this conversation.  That’s what the world needs.  That’s how we’re going to find solutions.  Enviroish kudos to that.

I started enviroish on the principle that everyone can take actions – big or small – to be mindful of their impact on others and the planet.  To not let the label “environmentalist” get in the way of actually doing good things that make sense.   Learning to listen to each other is an extension of that credo, this belief I have that at our cores everyone is good and cares.  Because I believe that the ties that bind us together in trying to do good will always be greater than the ties that divide. 

I look forward to being a small part of this conversation.   What do you think?  Who or what do you rely on to challenge your thinking?

12 Comments
mike
10/6/2015 09:49:20 am

depends on whether the dialogue is one-way or two-way. in California, it is a rarity to speak to someone eco- or left-leaning in an honest, respect 2-way true conversation. all too often one or both parties is unwilling to just listen to perspective rather than judge and immediately call the other party "wrong" or "nuts."

i feel for the Monsanto rep. that was brave. was she able to provide her (or monsanto's perspective) to the crowd? if so, were they willing to listen? or was it just a one way dialogue?

i am able to dialogue with you on many things, which i think is a blessing through and through. i am rarely able to do the same with your (former) colleagues on the same topics... i like the way this is headed :)

Reply
Megan link
10/6/2015 11:10:46 am

Same friend I reference above would totally agree on the California comment...she got a master's in environmental along with her JD at Stanford and the environmental crowd was pretty rough and non-inclusive to say the least. Not my environmental tribes finest feature (or moment fr that matter). I hope to encourage everyone to recognize that we enter conversations with bias and almost never allow for biases to be discovered and addressed. Goes for both sides of the aisle so to speak. Monsanto rep did the only thing she could do in the situation and show commitment to the conversation. I'm interested in the response to today's session with their CTO. It's a necessary dialogue. And I was thinking about you amigo with this post as well! Top of mind...we do dialogue on things. I actually didn't understand how unique that was until well into our relationship when we (apparently) finally mentioned things like politics. It's one of my prouder relationships from the sustainability perspective for that reason. Proof that the conversations can be had. It might have something more to do with you be a generally awesome human.... :)

Reply
Janice Person link
10/7/2015 07:07:35 pm

Agreed, I think there is so much to be learned and done in the middle rather than on some extreme perspective. Thanks for being willing to hear various perspectives... I had the chance to talk with several people after the session and tried to be sure people knew I was opened for dialogue even if that meant heated criticism. I wrote about it too. This is something I published on the work blog last year about the interaction. http://monsantoblog.com/2014/10/09/a-look-back-at-sxsw-eco/

Reply
Janice link
10/7/2015 06:16:18 pm

so good getting to know you so much better this year! And I am truly humbled by your characterization of things. I have to say the conversation around the environment and how we approach things to balance food production and the demand on the ecosystems is far too critical for hurt feelings to eliminate voices so we will continue to try to pull up a seat and join the conversation. Thank you for being at the table and asking questions on our role

Reply
Janice link
10/7/2015 06:19:26 pm

oh and I have to tell you I do consumer engagement for the company.... The director of sustainability is much smarter than me!

Reply
Megan link
10/8/2015 11:55:07 pm

Updated the reference to your role. Ready for the onslaught of comments? This is what open dialogue looks like right? (insert me hunkering down for internet haterade...) Haha. Totes worth it...I'm woman enough to stay in this conversation for the long haul :)

Reply
Janice link
10/8/2018 10:48:34 am

Saw this come back up in the memories feature on Facebook. Hope you are doing well!

Reply
Megan
11/30/2018 06:04:38 am

Thank you so much Janice! I am. October was a bit overwhelming because I transferred jobs internally at my company, but I'm excited to be in the new role. I SO enjoyed our connection at SXSW Eco back when, and appreciate you stopping by to say a quick hello. I have been a little offline with my blog but excited to get back into it in the coming months. Are you still blogging and actively awesome on social media? I'd love to follow your blog (again? I thought I was already, but my computers have changed...) to learn from an expert! :)

Reply
Janice link
11/30/2018 03:13:16 pm

Totally understand. I neglected my blog for quite a while and this fall relaunched -- now I'm pumped about it. I have gotten one set up to talk about cotton exclusively https://hundredpercentcotton.com and the other is lifestyle site where I talk travel, food and general farm stuff. It is https://jploveslife.com. Maybe once you get started we could guest post for each other. Could be fun.

Megan link
5/18/2019 09:04:38 pm

Hi Janice! I can't believe it's been 6 months since I commented back here. Ugh. I wanted to write this blogpost so many times and it just felt like it was to unfinished to ever get out the door! :) Your blog is so much lovelier and official looking! I worry mine isn't up to such a fun and high standard. What do you think? Still interested in doing a guest post? I am always looking for a new adventure ;)

Reply
Amy link
4/22/2019 10:57:50 pm

First time reading this blog, just wanted to say hi Meghan!

Reply
Megan link
5/18/2019 09:01:08 pm

Thanks Amy for stopping by and hello! I am glad you left a comment and enjoyed the read. I finally just posted a new blogpost in a year and a half...in case you are interested in more! Haha :) https://www.enviroish.com/blog/so-you-want-to-have-an-impact

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Enviro(ISH):

    (adj) balancing caring about the future of our planet with enjoying and living everyday life to the fullest

    Social(ish):

    Categories

    All
    DailyResistance
    EcoPartyDownload
    Energy & Climate
    Environmentalish
    EverydayEco
    Forests & Nature
    @Home
    Inclusion
    Inspirations
    Links I Love
    Mountainfilm
    Reuse
    @TheOffice
    Water & Oceans

    Archives

    October 2020
    November 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    September 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly